← Back to my journal

Short fiction · November 11, 2026

The Ninth Bar

An extra measure appears in a rehearsal. The clean version is not necessarily the one worth keeping.

The trouble started after the eighth measure.

We had agreed on eight. It was written on the chart, circled in black, and confirmed by three people who were all capable of counting. That should have been sufficient.

It wasn't.

The drummer lifted her sticks for the chorus. The bass arrived on time. I held the last note of the verse a second too long, reaching for a breath that hadn't appeared in rehearsal.

Nobody came in.

For one peculiar moment the whole room leaned toward the silence.

Then the bassist played four notes he didn't recognize. The drummer answered with a tap on the rim. I caught the next word late and sang it anyway, making the chorus arrive with its coat half on.

We stopped at the end.

“Who added a bar?” the drummer asked.

I looked at the chart. There was no ninth bar on it. This was a persuasive argument against its existence, although the speakers had just played it back for us.

The bassist shrugged. “You did.”

“I was waiting for you.”

“Then we're a very efficient committee.”

We played the recording again. The extra measure wasn't empty. There was a tiny scrape at the beginning, the bass feeling around for somewhere to land, the rim tap, and my late breath before the chorus. It sounded like a room making up its mind in public.

We tried to correct it.

On the next take we entered exactly when the chart told us to. The chorus was good. Clean. Confident. Every sound arrived with a little name tag.

“Better,” said the drummer.

“Certainly easier to count,” said the bassist.

I asked for one more take.

This time we left the chart on the floor.

The bass tried the four unfamiliar notes. The drummer didn't copy the old rim tap; she answered with something lighter. I didn't hold the note quite as long. The chorus arrived late again, but not in the same way.

By the end we had three versions: one tidy, one accidental, one deliberate enough to be suspicious.

The drummer labeled them 8, 9, and 9-ish.

I asked which one we should keep.

She put down her sticks. “You wrote the song.”

“That's not an answer.”

“No,” she said. “It's your problem.”

I left all three takes in the folder.

The one labeled 9-ish was the first I played when I came back.

— Carly